Bear's Blog

5 Ways to NOT Help Your Smoker Quit

by Bear on November 29, 2010

Plant and your spouse plants with you; weed and you weed alone.” ”
—- Jean-Jaques Rousseau

When it comes to smoking, everybody knows the score: it’s a zillion to three, smokers lose. Even smokers know this.
The only question now for our country’s 46 million smokers is how can they be done with this goofy habit, this life and death game? According to research from the Center for Disease Control, the great majority of smokers (70+% ) are tired of the game and just want to know how they can sneak off the field, into the locker room, out of the stadium. It’s a rout. Smokers want to get back into civilian clothes, blend in with the natives. They truly don’t need convincing.
So how do we help our smokers quit? On the surface, it’s easy: We just love them unconditionally, support them, give them time and space to get the job done, offer non-judging curiosity and, most importantly, humor and light-heartedness.
And then what? A more useful question might be how do we NOT help our smokers quit? Are we doing anything that makes it harder for them to quit?
Aneta Comensecu, aged sixty-three, made it harder. According to newspaper reports, her husband, Marin, died at age 76. In his will he stipulated that if Aneta wanted to inherit his estate she would have to smoke at least five cigarettes a day for the rest of her life. This, he said, was her punishment for waging daily war against his smoking habit and putting him through “forty years of hell.” Aneta challenged the will. “I’d rather lose everything than touch a cigarette,” she said.
Poor Aneta. And poor Marin. If Marin had been in hell for forty years, we know that Aneta was right there along with him. Can we blame tobacco? Did Marin smoke because he couldn’t help it and Aneta just wouldn’t cut him any slack? Or did Aneta’s harping just make it that much harder to quit?
Obviously, some smokers live with nonsmokers and both sides experience a heaven on earth during their years together. And countless smokers have quit because they were inspired by their lovers, brothers, sisters, parents and friends. Clearly, it’s not the tobacco that makes for heaven or hell; it’s how we approach tobacco.
So what approach do we drop that doesn’t work. Here are the basic five:
1.) Don’t be a cop to your smoker. Alas, our smokers are already handcuffed, and know the difference between right and wrong. Our smokers will not escape from either the physical or social laws surrounding tobacco. Smokers already meet countless numbers of people quite willing to play the cop role, telling them right from wrong. So we can put away the badge. Our smokers’ “wrong-doing” is obvious. Our smokers have already been “arrested.” We can relax away from the “cop role.” Be on their side. The heavy hand of the law need not be our hand.
2.) Don’t be your smoker’s doctor. Researchers report that most smokers estimate the health risks of tobacco higher than do non-smokers. So we are not obliged to make diagnoses, or prognoses. Smokers know better than we that smoking is not healthy. They’re already frightened enough. No need to add to their fears. If we practice our own healthy lifestyle, our smokers will notice. Joy, not fear, is the road to health. Our smokers already know the dangers. Our reminders don’t help. Reminders just add to the fear bag.
3.) Don’t be your smoker’s Hall Monitor. We don’t need to monitor the times our smokers go out for a smoke, or count the number of smokes they’re smoking. Such close monitoring doesn’t do our smokers any good. In fact, our monitoring leads to more smoking, or secret smoking. And such monitoring doesn’t help our mood. We have other ways to help our smokers. Counting smokes is not one of them!
4.) Don’t be your smoker’s psychotherapist. Our smokers don’t not need our analyzing. Our smokers just needs our love, our laughter, our support, our free and easy company. By the hour, the week and the month.
5.) And finally, don’t be your smoker’s preacher. Our smokers don’t need sermons. They’ve heard it before (probably from us!) Most smokers already give themselves a daily series of hellfire and brimstone sermons about smoking that sufficiently chastise them, keep them cowed. Again, our smokers just needs our love, our laughter, our support.
For our smokers to finally be free of smoking they will have to change not only their physical behavior but more importantly change the way they think and feel about smoking. Seems only fair that, to help them, we change our own way of thinking and feeling and acting about smoking?
We harp on our smokers because we love them. For the same reason, let’s stop harping, offer instead our love, patience, insight and most all, humor. This is what they most need from their traveling companions.

{ 0 comments }

Hamburgers and a Worried Father

by Bear on October 23, 2009

We're in this together!

We're in this together!

Had a worried father call me, half a dozen times or so, about his teenage son who was smoking pot and had graduated (devolved?) to tobacco, the “hard stuff.” Welcome to parenthood. Welcome to human hood. If you don’t laugh, you cry.

It was in fact his son’s tobacco use that most worried the father. (BTW, papa was probably wise in his selection of “worries.” Studies show the dangers of tobacco to be ten times, even a hundred times more worrisome than the dangers of pot smoking, though in our culture, with parents in particular, we tend to reverse these findings.) Papa set an appointment for his son to come see me.

I generally refrain from such “set-ups.”

“I think he really does want to quit, “the father said. “Or that’s what he tells me. Maybe you can judge.”
I don’t want to judge. I enjoy working with smokers. I enjoy working with parents (and kids and spouses and friends) of smokers. I don’t enjoy taking sides—getting in the middle— of the battles that are so often ongoing between them. When the non-smoker sets up the appointment for the smoker, I am suddenly a solider, conscripted into the wars. Most often I refuse such conscription.
In the tobacco wars, I’m a conscientious objector, a non-combatant. My destiny is to work with the refugees of this war.
Through our phone conversations, the father and I had developed a warm, though budding relationship. So more for the father’s sake than for the son’s, this time I let the father set the appointment.
Alas, (as often happens) the young guy didn’t show for his appointment. (Again, you laugh or you cry.) What to do?
For me, I suddenly had a little unexpected breathing room in my day. I could catch up on some paperwork, or (more likely) go surfing for fun stuff on the web. For dad and the son, I know, the battles, overt or covert, probably began again. (Another reason I generally refrain from accepting appointments made by a non-smoker for a smoker. I don’t want to be the excuse for one more battle in their tobacco wars!)
I suspect I’m going to get a call here soon. (The “no-show,” as we call them in the business, happened just yesterday.) I suspect the father will apologize— sorry, sorry—then ask what he should do now. I suspect he’ll secretly, if not openly, want to set another appointment.
“Just give the kid a dutch rub,” I’d like to tell him. “Laugh and poke him in the ribs. Take him fishing, hiking. Take him to a ball game. Or make him a hamburger. Just be there for him. Be with him. Give him space. Give him sunshine. Water his roots. Nourish him, with all the peace and joy and compassion you can muster.”
It’s a tricky, delicate art, this raising of kids. We need to know when to push, and when to stand back. And we don’t always know. The clues are often misleading. So we goof up, and then try again.
“Practice your own joy,” I’ll tell the father. “Practice your own peace. The kid will catch on.”
What the alternative? Practice anger, resentment, blame? Practice warfare?
One of the wisest men to have ever lived was once asked, “How many times should we forgive? Seven times?”
The wise man replied, “Seven times seven, and seven times again.”
Welcome to parenthood. Welcome to human-hood. Make him a hamburger.

{ 0 comments }

Basic Observations: A Baker’s Dozen, plus One

October 21, 2009

1. We can observe that if and when we come across some new information, or gain a new perspective, then helping our smokers quit may turn out to be much easier, more natural and spontaneous than it was prior to our gaining this new information, this new perspective. 2. We can observe that many smokers [...]

Read the full article →

What to Do When You Hear Your Smoker Cough

August 18, 2009

                One reason we want to help our smokers quit is simply because we love them (or like them) and want them to be healthy. When we hear our smokers cough — be it occasional or constant— it reminds us again (and again and again) of the need for our smoker to quit smoking. It’s [...]

Read the full article →

“Either quit or move out. That’s your option.”

August 12, 2009

One of my colleagues is teaching a stop smoking class at the local old folks’ complex. (I could have taught the class—but I graciously let her do it!) The housing complex is a government run deal, where most of the old folks are low income, fixed-income, dancing their social security type of lifestyle. Lots of [...]

Read the full article →

Our Two-Step “Helping” Process

August 3, 2009

  THE  HIGHEST GOAL IS NOT TO JUST HELP OUR SMOKERS QUIT SMOKING.  (As Mark Twain said,“It’s easy to quit smoking. I’ve done it a thousand times.”  And started back up a thousand times!) THE HIGHEST GOAL IS TO HELP OUR SMOKERS  LEARN   TO FINALLY BE NATURALLY, EASILY, AT PEACE  WITH NOT SMOKING!           The Freedom School’s Brave and Radical Strategy: In [...]

Read the full article →

The Basics: A Radically Peaceful Strategy

July 22, 2009

     The problem: Smoking causes conflict, causes wars.         Smoking causes conflict in the smoker himself, or herself (whether she admits it or not.) Obviously, there’s a physical conflict. The body resists and fights against the 4,000 toxins that accompany tobacco smoke. And yet the body craves and relies on the nicotine that also accompanies [...]

Read the full article →

Does Our Fear Help or Hinder Their Quitting?

July 18, 2009

    Most of us are (quite naturally) afraid for our smokers, what smoking is doing to them (and, of course, to us, and the rest of the family!) It is our fear for our smokers that leads us to want to help them quit!        But our smokers are also dealing with fear. “The only thing [...]

Read the full article →

My Teen Is Smoking– What to Do?

July 16, 2009

     A dad called recently, wanting some help with his sixteen year old smoker son. Tricky, this.      “He doesn’t talk much,” the dad said. “Especially about this.”       As we know, most teens talk marathon talks with their friends. It’s with their folks that many teens clam up. The Folks have been instructing them [...]

Read the full article →

Smoking in Front of the Grandkids?

July 13, 2009

         Talking with the wife of a smoker-friend yesterday— he was out of earshot.  “What can I do?” she asked.       “Love him, enjoy him, be at peace with him,” was my seemingly trite response. “Give him a Dutch rub.”          She was worried, because both of their grown kids were smokers— though one [...]

Read the full article →